Education Savings Options: Picking the Right Tool for the Job
There’s no one-size-fits-all approach when it comes to saving for a child’s education. Each family has different goals—some are thinking strictly about college, others are juggling private K-12 expenses, and some just want to build up funds with flexibility. The key is choosing the right tool for the job. Here’s a breakdown of three common education savings options—529 Plans, Coverdell ESAs, and UGMA/UTMA custodial accounts—and how they stack up when it comes to taxes, flexibility, and financial aid.
529 Plans: A Long-Term College Powerhouse
If college is the goal, a 529 Plan is often the go-to. These accounts are built for higher education and come with solid tax perks: your money grows tax-free, and as long as it’s used for qualified expenses—like tuition, books, and housing—you won’t pay taxes on withdrawals. Some states sweeten the deal with tax deductions or credits for contributions.
There are no income limits to contribute, and the contribution limits are high (over $300,000 in most states). Plus, the account owner (usually a parent) stays in control. When considering an education savings option, you might wonder what happens if your child decides not to go to college. One of the benefits of a 529 is that it can be used for trade school, transferred to a family member (from grandparents and cousins to great-grandchildren and in-laws), or rolled into a Roth IRA (up to $35,000).
The trade-off? If you pull money out for non-education expenses, you’ll face income tax and a 10% penalty on the earnings. While you can now use up to $10,000 per year for K–12 tuition, it’s still not the most flexible account out there. That said, because it’s considered a parental asset, it has a relatively minor effect on financial aid calculations.
Coverdell ESAs: Best for K–12 Flexibility
Coverdell ESAs cover a wider range of education expenses than 529s, including things like tutoring, school supplies, and even technology, making them a solid option for families looking at private K–12 education.
Like a 529, Coverdell earnings grow tax-free and stay tax-free if used for qualified expenses. But here’s the catch: contributions are capped at $2,000 per year per child, and high-income households (over $110,000 single or $220,000 married) can’t contribute at all. Also, the funds must be used before the beneficiary turns 30, or you’ll face penalties.
If the parent owns the account, it’s treated like a parental asset, which helps keep the impact on financial aid relatively low. Just know that once the child reaches the age of majority, they get full control of the funds.
UGMA/UTMA Accounts: Freedom, With Trade-Offs
UGMA and UTMA accounts aren’t limited to education, which makes them the most flexible. Want to help your child buy a car, pay for a wedding, or just have a financial head start? This is your lane. There’s no annual contribution limit (aside from gift tax thresholds), and the money can be used for anything that benefits the child.
But flexibility comes with strings. These accounts don’t offer the same tax advantages—only the first $1,250 in earnings is tax-free, and the next $1,250 is taxed at the child’s rate. More importantly, the money legally belongs to the child and counts heavily against them when applying for financial aid.
So, What’s the Move?
For long-term college savings, go with a 529 Plan. If you need to cover K–12 tuition or a mix of expenses, a Coverdell ESA could fit. If you want maximum flexibility, even if education isn’t the only goal, an UGMA or UTMA gives the most freedom but comes with some big trade-offs.
Choose the account that lines up with your priorities, and make sure your savings plan works for both your goals and your student’s future.
Did You Know?
Your employer sponsors this financial wellness benefit from Francis. The benefit connects you with down-to-earth financial planners who educate and advise on any money matters…without the sales pitch. We are exclusively engaged by employers like yours and have no investment products to sell, so you can feel confident that you will always receive objective advice.
Your financial planner will help you set priorities and achieve your money goals, without judgment or financial jargon. Know that all discussions are kept strictly confidential. This service is offered as an employee benefit with no per-session co-pays, so you can meet with a financial planner as often as you wish. Services are paid by your retirement plan or your employer.
Connecting with a financial planner is easy! Here’s how:
- Visit FrancisWay.com > Services > Participant Portal
- Call (866) 232-6457
Download the free mobile app (Search for Francis LLC)
